|
Some years ago (September 29, 2022) brother Sean Griffin invited me on his YT channel to discuss whether or not the Son of God literally pre-existed his conception in Mary’s womb (and birth in Bethlehem). There were four of us involved in the discussion (two vs. two), and it was completely cordial and non-condemning towards either position (literal vs. notional pre-existence). I’m not one who holds to believing in Christ’s literal pre-existence (or not) as salvational. I think it’s fine if one chooses to believe either way, so long as they confess Yeshua as the Son of the Most High, the promised Messiah.
During our discussion, Psalm 110:3 was brought up in the Old Greek (commonly called the Septuagint - Psalm 109:3 LXX [hereafter 110:3]). While this verse reads (in the MT-LSB) “Your people will offer themselves freely in the day of Your power; In the splendor of holiness, from the womb of the dawn, The dew of Your youthfulness will be Yours,” in the Old Greek it reads (LXX-NETS) “With you is rule on a day of your power among the splendors of the holy ones. From the womb, before morning star, I brought you forth.” The OSB renders that last sentence, “I have begotten You from the womb, before the morning star.” Even though I’ve studied the readings from the Old Greek for several years (looking at NT quotations of the OT) my fellow Christian brothers - Sean and WesBlaze - brought something up here that I’d never seen before. I read the passage they presented and just told them it looked like a good point for their position, that the Son of God was brought forth or begotten before the morning-star (which they argued to be the s-u-n) existed. It’s wisdom to acknowledge another’s good debate point if you have not studied a text. Far too often I can tell that when asked a question, people are scurrying in their mind for an answer they have not studied out. In this case, I’d never even seen the alternate reading in spite of many LXX studies of my own. I tucked away the information at that time, and it’s only now that I’m ready to make some comments. (I was pricked on the text just the other day, while working my farm tractor and listening to a recent debate where Psalm 110 was brought up for a good ten minutes.) My first point is that no NT author cites Psalm 110:3 as a proof-text for Christ’s literal pre-existence, or cites it in anywhere for that matter. This is in spite of the NT authors being highly aware of this Psalm. I’ve read from numerous sources that Psalm 110:1 may be the most often cited and alluded to text of the OT in the NT (approximately 22x), where Yahweh speaks to David’s Lord (or lord, NRSV) concerning his seat at His right hand. For example, this text is cited by Peter (as Luke records) in the famous Acts sermon concerning the resurrection of Christ (Acts 2:32-34). Once God raised Jesus, He exalted him to His right hand until all his enemies were made a footstool for his feet. Another one I’ve often brought up in discussions is Ephesians 1:20 (LSB), “which He worked in Christ, by raising Him from the dead and seating Him at His right hand in the heavenly places.” The sequence is (1) resurrection from the dead, then (2) seated (enthroned) at the Almighty’s right hand. Another verse in Psalm 110 that is mentioned in the NT is verse 4 which speaks of Yeshua’s priesthood in the order of Melchizedek. There are five explicit quotations of this in the NT: Hebrews 5:6; 6:20; 7:17, 21, all which speak of Yeshua’s priesthood in heaven, after his resurrection. Couple this with the same Hebrews author pulling from Psalm 110:1 in Hebrews 1:13; 10:12-13 (along with allusions in Hebrews 1:3; 5:10; 8:1; 12:2). So the Hebrews author recognizes this particular Psalm (in two of its verses) to be a ‘post-resurrection (exalted) Son Psalm,’ not a ‘pre-existent Son Psalm.’ As I was meditating on the aforementioned, alternate reading of Psalm 110:3, my mind went to similar language back in Psalm 2, concerning the begetting of the Son. Psalm 2:7 speaks of the decree of Yahweh (NRSV): “He said to Me, ‘You are my Son; today I have begotten you.” The word begotten here (in the Greek text) is gennaō, a word that can refer to an actual begettal of a son (in conception and birth), but can also refer to being brought forth in some manner. I know this because Psalm 2:7 is another text that is cited by a NT author in reference to the RESURRECTION of the Messiah rather than his conception in the womb of the virgin Miriam. The author Luke (in Acts 13) records Paul as preaching about Yeshua in a Jewish synagogue, and there Paul preaches the resurrection of Christ from the dead, that the Almighty raised him up (13:30, 33a) fulfilling was was written in the second Psalm, specifically Psalm 2:7. Acts 13:33a mentions God raising up Jesus, and Acts 13:34a says “He raised him up from the dead.” Right in between the two (Acts 13:33b) Psalm 2:7 is quoted. So “Today I have begotten you” is a reference to Yahweh bringing forth Yeshua from death to life. Again, a resurrection text. Hebrews 5:5-6 (NRSV) is pertinent here: “So also Christ did not glorify himself in becoming a high priest, but was appointed by the one who said to him, ‘You are my Son, today I have begotten you:’ as he says also in another place, ‘You are a priest forever, according to the order of Melchizedek.’” The author here cites Psalm 2:7 and Psalm 110:4 back-to-back, both referencing a post-resurrection Christ. Yeshua did not obtain his priesthood on earth (Hebrews 8:1-4) but received it up in the heavens, after his resurrection from the dead. This takes us back full circle to the text I’d never heard of at the time of that friendly debate, Psalm 110:3, which uses the language of begetting just like Psalm 2. “From the womb, before morning-star, I brought you forth (or “begot you,” gennaō). (LXX-NETS)” Think about it: Psalm 110:1 is a resurrection text (according to the author of Hebrews). Psalm 110:4 is a resurrection text (according to the author of Hebrews, concerning the Melchizedek priesthood). The same goes for the earlier Psalm 2:7 (according to Luke and the author of Hebrews). Why could Psalm 110:3 not also be a post-resurrection text? I realize the author of Hebrews doesn’t cite this verse specifically (neither does any other author in the NT), but this understanding would make the most sense when stringing all the verses in Psalm 110 together in a cohesive manner, especially in light of the earlier begetting language in Psalm 2, later applied to bringing Yeshua forth from the dead (Acts 13:33-34; Hebrews 5:5-6). What I’m suggesting is that Psalm 110:3 (in the Old Greek) can be understood as Yahweh raising Yeshua from death (from the womb of the earth, Sheol/Hades) before the morning-star (the morning or the dawn). I realize this means we must read the word “womb” metaphorically, but a metaphorical reading is still necessary if we read the verse to speak of the begetting of a pre-existent Son; there was no literal womb back then that would have brought forth the Son. Also, the Greek text of 1 Samuel 30:17 and Job 11:17 shows that morning-star (Greek = heōsforus) may refer at times to simply the dawn of the day, and we know that when the women came to the tomb to check on the body of Yeshua, it was yet dark (John 20:1), and they saw that the stone was already rolled away. Psalm 110:3 then appears to me to be another prophetic text speaking towards the resurrection of Yeshua, aligning beautifully with Psalm 110 verses 1 and 4. I did check to see if there were any ante-Nicene “church fathers” who held to this interpretation, not that we have to side with them, but just out of my curiosity and respect of past interpreters. The first to cite the verse specifically is Justin Martyr, in his “Dialogue with Trypho.” In one text (V1p210 [of the 10 volume series, 1987]) he appears to link it somewhat to the resurrection, although I can’t be for certain, because elsewhere he does appear to use the verse to teach literal pre-existence (V1p229). Clement of Alexandria (V2p173) cites the verse in connection with John 1:1 to show that salvation in Christ was from of old (and not a new concept). Tertullian interestingly cites the verse (V3p448) as pertaining to the birth of Christ in Luke 2; he focuses on the birth happening at night, and the angels giving praise for the Christ-child. There are other references to the verse (ANCF), and some Christians have used the verse to teach Christ’s literal pre-existence, I just disagree with their assessment for the reasons I’ve given in this study. Again, the earliest citation of Psalm 110:3 is in Justin Martyr; no NT author ever cites the verse to teach Christ’s pre-existence, or quotes the verse period. I’m persuaded that Psalm 110:3 is better exegeted as pertaining to Christ’s being begotten from the dead, during the night before sunrise, in light of Psalm 2:7, Psalm 110:1,4, Acts 13:33-34, and several texts in Hebrews concerning Christ’s priesthood post-resurrection. I hope and pray this short study has been beneficial to you for your own studies. May we all continue to search the Scriptures in order to understand truth more and more.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorBlog by Matthew Janzen. Lover of Yahweh, Yeshua, my wife and 5 children. All else is commentary. Archives
October 2026
Categories
All
|
RSS Feed